| Q1 11:22 | Buffalo | +1 yd | Branden Oliver rush for 1 yard for a TOUCHDOWN. |
| Q1 14:30 | Buffalo | +54 yd | Joe Licata pass complete to Alex Neutz for 54 yards to the Bayl 21 for a 1ST down. |
| Q1 11:22 | Buffalo | +0 yd | Patrick Clarke extra point GOOD. |
| Q1 10:28 | Baylor | +61 yd | Bryce Petty pass complete to Tevin Reese for 61 yards for a TOUCHDOWN. |
| Q1 10:28 | Baylor | +0 yd | Aaron Jones extra point GOOD. |
| Q1 7:20 | Baylor | +44 yd | Bryce Petty pass complete to Tevin Reese for 44 yards to the Buff 39 for a 1ST down. |
| Q1 6:37 | Baylor | +0 yd | Aaron Jones extra point GOOD. |
| Q1 6:37 | Baylor | +3 yd | Shock Linwood rush for 3 yards for a TOUCHDOWN. |
| Q1 3:52 | Baylor | +0 yd | Aaron Jones extra point GOOD. |
| Q1 3:52 | Baylor | +8 yd | Lache Seastrunk rush for 8 yards for a TOUCHDOWN. |
| Q1 2:11 | Buffalo | +14 yd | Joe Licata pass complete to Alex Neutz for 14 yards for a TOUCHDOWN. |
| Q1 2:52 | Buffalo | +49 yd | Joe Licata pass complete to Alex Neutz for 49 yards to the Bayl 13 for a 1ST down. |
| Q1 1:04 | Baylor | +83 yd | Bryce Petty pass complete to Antwan Goodley for 83 yards for a TOUCHDOWN. |
| Q1 1:04 | Baylor | +0 yd | Aaron Jones extra point GOOD. |
| Q2 13:10 | Buffalo | +20 yd | Tyler Grassman punt for 44 yards, returned by Levi Norwood for 20 yards to the Buff 45. |
| Q2 11:27 | Baylor | +0 yd | Aaron Jones extra point GOOD. |
| Q2 11:27 | Baylor | +5 yd | Bryce Petty rush for 5 yards for a TOUCHDOWN. |
| Q2 9:05 | Buffalo | +7 yd | Joe Licata pass intercepted by Xavien Howard at the Bayl 31, returned for 7 yards to the Bayl 38. |
| Q2 7:11 | Baylor | +1 yd | Lache Seastrunk rush for 1 yard for a TOUCHDOWN. |
| Q2 7:11 | Baylor | +0 yd | Aaron Jones extra point GOOD. |
| Q2 6:48 | Buffalo | +62 yd | Joe Licata pass complete to Alex Neutz for 62 yards to the Bayl 13 for a 1ST down. |
| Q2 5:18 | Baylor | +0 yd | Aaron Jones extra point GOOD. |
| Q2 3:52 | Baylor | +33 yd | Lache Seastrunk rush for 33 yards for a TOUCHDOWN. |
| Q2 3:52 | Baylor | +0 yd | Aaron Jones extra point GOOD. |
| Q2 1:00 | Baylor | +20 yd | Bryce Petty pass complete to Tevin Reese for 20 yards to the Bayl 48 for a 1ST down. |
| Q3 13:56 | Baylor | +6 yd | Shock Linwood rush for 6 yards for a TOUCHDOWN. |
| Q3 14:14 | Baylor | +40 yd | Bryce Petty pass complete to Jerod Monk for 40 yards to the Buff 19 for a 1ST down. |
| Q3 13:56 | Baylor | +0 yd | Aaron Jones extra point GOOD. |
| Q3 10:45 | Baylor | +20 yd | Seth Russell pass complete to Levi Norwood for 20 yards to the Bayl 30 for a 1ST down. |
| Q3 7:16 | Baylor | +20 yd | Seth Russell pass complete to Corey Coleman for 20 yards to the Bayl 45 for a 1ST down. |
| Q3 6:30 | Buffalo | +45 yd | Alex Zordich pass complete to Ron Willoughby for 45 yards to the Bayl 36 for a 1ST down. |
| Q4 10:22 | Baylor | +53 yd | Seth Russell pass complete to Jay Lee for 53 yards for a TOUCHDOWN. |
| Q4 10:44 | Baylor | +21 yd | Seth Russell rush for 21 yards to the Bayl 47 for a 1ST down. |
| Q4 10:22 | Baylor | +0 yd | Kyle Peterson extra point GOOD. |